Honest Peptide vs Modern Aminos
Two top US peptide sources scored on the identical published formula: lab credibility, shipping, pricing, operating history, and transparency.
- Honest Peptide
- 7.71/10
Honest Peptide
- Modern Aminos
- 7.88/10
Modern Aminos
Affiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy. It never changes a score or rank.
Factor by factor
- 8.1Lab Credibilityweight 55%8.7
- 8.0Shipping & Refundweight 20%7.0
- 8.1Pricingweight 15%7.8
- 2.8Operating Historyweight 5%4.9
- 6.0Transparencyweight 5%5.5
- 18Certificates confirmed at the lab32
- 3Labs named on certificates3
Show as a table
| Category | Honest Peptide | Modern Aminos |
|---|---|---|
| Lab Credibility | 8.1 | 8.7 |
| Shipping & Refund | 8.0 | 7.0 |
| Pricing | 8.1 | 7.8 |
| Operating History | 2.8 | 4.9 |
| Transparency | 6.0 | 5.5 |
| Overall | 7.71 | 7.88 |
Products both carry, price for price
| Peptide | Honest Peptideper unit | Modern Aminosper unit |
|---|---|---|
| BPC-157Guide → | $4.90/mg | $5.40/mg |
| TB-500Guide → | $6.30/mg | $5.90/mg |
| GHK-CuGuide → | $0.49/mg | $0.64/mg |
| CJC-1295Guide → | $7.00/mg | $10.40/mg |
| IpamorelinGuide → | $4.90/mg | $6.40/mg |
| Semax | $4.90/mg | $4.20/mg |
| Selank | $4.50/mg | $4.50/mg |
| Melanotan-2 | $3.15/mg | $3.80/mg |
| Sermorelin | $5.90/mg | $7.40/mg |
| Tesamorelin | $7.00/mg | $7.10/mg |
| NAD+ | $0.11/mg | $0.10/mg |
| MOTS-c | $3.50/mg | $2.60/mg |
| AOD-9604 | $6.30/mg | $7.80/mg |
| CJC-1295 + Ipamorelin | $5.00/mg | $5.20/mg |
How they compare: the verdict
Modern Aminos takes this matchup by a razor-thin margin, 7.88 to 7.71 on the published formula. Its biggest edge is operating history, where it scores 4.9 against Honest Peptide's 2.8.
It isn't a clean sweep. Honest Peptide actually edges ahead on shipping & refunds (8.0 vs 7.0), so if that factor matters most to you it's worth weighing.
On lab evidence, the heaviest-weighted factor, both Honest Peptide and Modern Aminos have independently verified third-party COAs, so the gap comes down to the other categories.
Across the 14 peptides both carry, Honest Peptide is cheaper per unit more often (Honest Peptide wins on 9, Modern Aminos on 4). The price-for-price table below has the detail, per mg (or per IU or mL for products sold that way).
Affiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy. It never changes a score or rank.
Honest Peptide vs Modern Aminos: FAQ
Honest Peptide or Modern Aminos: which is better?
Modern Aminos takes this matchup by a razor-thin margin, 7.88 to 7.71 on the published formula. Its biggest edge is operating history, where it scores 4.9 against Honest Peptide's 2.8. It isn't a clean sweep. Honest Peptide actually edges ahead on shipping & refunds (8.0 vs 7.0), so if that factor matters most to you it's worth weighing. On lab evidence, the heaviest-weighted factor, both Honest Peptide and Modern Aminos have independently verified third-party COAs, so the gap comes down to the other categories. Across the 14 peptides both carry, Honest Peptide is cheaper per unit more often (Honest Peptide wins on 9, Modern Aminos on 4). The price-for-price table below has the detail, per mg (or per IU or mL for products sold that way).
Do Honest Peptide and Modern Aminos both use third-party testing?
Honest Peptide: independently verified third-party COAs. Modern Aminos: independently verified third-party COAs.
How was this comparison scored?
Both vendors are scored on the identical published formula: lab credibility 55%, shipping 20%, pricing 15%, operating history 5%, transparency 5%. When third-party testing cannot be independently verified, a testing gate holds the score under a cap that starts at 6.0 and rises by at most 2.5 points for operating history, shipping and reviews. Neither vendor can pay to change a score.
More comparisons
Other head-to-heads featuring Honest Peptide or Modern Aminos.